This post is inspired by my brother Max Urai, the better writer of the family – two steps ahead in his thinking, as always. Why literature is a gift-economy (Rekto:Verso, in Dutch). I shamelessly copied some quotations.
The pursuit of scientific knowledge works by virtue of the work of others. We stand on the shoulders of giants, re-mix and improve, discuss and critique; and we hope to leave our communities a bit better than we found them.
Such intellectual exchange can be characterised as a gift economy. This system operates very differently than the familiar market economy, where a trade of specified value is made, and both parties then go their own way. In the gift economy, on the other hand, our gifts cannot be precisely quantified. Rather, receiving gifts ties us the broader community, and commits us to return a gift – at some point, in some form, to someone (but never exactly).
Reciprocity in life and in the academy is a feature of infinite play. Reciprocity colonizes your future by enrolling you in longitudinal practices of giving and getting. When your child finishes college, you do not present them with a bill for all of the expenses they cost you growing up. If you do, you are planning to never see them again.
Bruce R. Caron, 2021
Continue reading “Science as a gift economy”